A Botanist's Guide to Society and Secrets skilfully portrays the challenges faced by a woman in a male-dominated profession in the 1900s without compromising Saffron's character. However, the pacing of the book may disappoint mystery lovers, as progress on the main tasks is delayed by sub-plots. Overall, A Botanist's Guide to Society and Secrets offers an enjoyable read, but its pacing may leave readers wanting more.

All things considered, The Hunting Moon is a good sequel to The Luminaries, offering a fresh perspective on Hemlock Falls and even the terrifying dwellings within the forest. The book's second half will keep you engrossed, and even its sporadic and pointless romantic subplot doesn't stop the reader from having a thrilling time.